Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'SWINDON NEWS' to 80360 or email »
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Got a story? EMAIL US, call us on 01793 501806 or text us at 80360, starting your message
with 'SWINDON NEWS'
10:30am Tuesday 15th July 2008
SWINDON has been thrusted into the national spotlight today by the council's proposals to pull speed cameras off the town's streets.
The council is reviewing its involvement with the Swindon and Wiltshire Camera Safety Partnership and considering whether to spend its £400,000-a-year contribution elsewhere.
What do you think about proposals to pull out of the camera safety partnership?
Have your say below
A decision will be made by September.
Council leader Rod Bluh said that they were not going to compromise on safety but were taking the opportunity to review how the money is used.
"A huge amount of money is being raised by speed cameras and we are seeking better ways of ensuring road safety without penalising motorists," he said.
In November, the Advertiser reported that former Coun Andy James had branded the cameras a stealth tax and hatched a plan to demand the Government returned all the cash from Swindon cameras to the council.
In January, Road Safety Minister Jim Fitzpatrick refused to hand back the cash generated by the cameras.
And yesterday the Adver reported that Swindon South MP Anne Snelgrove had backed residents' calls for the speed cameras in Queens Drive to be reinstated.
This morning, Coun Bluh spoke on Radio Four's Today programme and appeared on GMTV.
The story has also appeared in a number of national newspapers, including the front page of the Daily Express.
In May, we polled nearly 500 people asking them whether the town needed speed cameras, and 52 per cent them said no.
But what do you think? Should the council pull out of the Swindon and Wiltshire Camera Safety Partnership or remain in it?
Do you think speed cameras save lives or are they just a moneymaking device? Have you say below.
The feedbacker, England says...
10:58am Tue 15 Jul 08
emmylou83, Stratton says...
10:59am Tue 15 Jul 08
we are seeking better ways of ensuring road safety without penalising motorists," he said.
Denis Cummins, Swindon says...
11:15am Tue 15 Jul 08
LA, says...
11:17am Tue 15 Jul 08
Grumpy old man, Swindon says...
11:17am Tue 15 Jul 08
Andy_C, Swindon says...
11:20am Tue 15 Jul 08
thenoose, Swindon says...
11:29am Tue 15 Jul 08
Robins69, swindon says...
11:38am Tue 15 Jul 08
worz, Wootton Bassett says...
11:44am Tue 15 Jul 08
Surely with a bit of thought there could be some kind of electronic limiter that could be fitted to cars that would automaticaly adjust according to what road you are on.
yeti, swindon says...
11:58am Tue 15 Jul 08
Grumpy old man, Swindon says...
12:03pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Robin Harris, Swindon says...
12:08pm Tue 15 Jul 08
yeti, swindon says...
12:15pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Grumpy old man wrote:i have no idea of the accidents in the area?
Yeti, that speed camera has been out of action for some time now. Could you remind me how many accidents there have been on that 100yd stretch since? (forget the rest of the road as that wouldn't be covered by the speed camera anyway)
Grumpy old man, Swindon says...
12:35pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Claire, Swindon says...
12:41pm Tue 15 Jul 08
yeti, swindon says...
12:51pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Grumpy old man wrote:completely agree
Well I'll go ahead with my guess. I'd wager zero, zilch, nadda, nil point. Point is, a speed camera does not discriminate - a car weaving between lanes, with the driver on his phone while drinking some coffee and having a ciggy, whilst applying makeup but under the speed limit will not be caught by any speed prevention measure. However, a safe, sensible middle aged bloke who is being observant all around him and goes at 5mph above a speed limit that was set donkeys years ago will be caught and fined. What we need is real traffic police with a remit to catch BAD driving, not fast driving. (the two are not mutually exclusive - bad driving could include driving too fast for the conditions but within speed limit) You yourself hit the nail on the head when you said you saw plenty of POOR driving. That can be but is not always fast driving. What we really need is a "Stupid" camera but they haven't invented that yet! :-)
Global Templar, Marlborough says...
1:19pm Tue 15 Jul 08
roy bezzant, swindon says...
1:24pm Tue 15 Jul 08
jantheman, Swindon says...
1:33pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez, Swindon says...
1:38pm Tue 15 Jul 08
trend, swindon says...
2:02pm Tue 15 Jul 08
redhousecomputers, Prioryvale says...
2:21pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Thandar, Swindon says...
2:25pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Chris Paisley, Location, Location. says...
2:25pm Tue 15 Jul 08
redhousecomputers, Prioryvale says...
2:36pm Tue 15 Jul 08
jantheman wrote:Interesting how you bring up the topic of schools in the area, there were schools along Queens Drive before the speed camera was invented, but better road policing, meant that the road was safer, however should we not start imposing fines and perhaps custodial sentences for anyone caught walking outside of a pedestrian crossing, or trying to cross a dual carriage way in between cars instead of using the foot bridge provided, I myself and am cyclist and a pedestrian when I have had something to drink/ need the exercise (delete as applicable) and have little problem in using traffic lights etc to make my way safely home from the pub, it is evident to me that these are just revenue generators, Now if a school happened to be in a small village on a fast piece of road then it would be understandable to have a camera in the vicinity and I would welcome it. However I am a firm believer in education in varying degrees of severity.
I have read the comments on this site and people mention no accidents or deaths For Example Queeens Drive has 2 schools and a college Surely we should retain the speed cameras for Safety reasons As for SBC looking to reduce costs Why on this subject surely as residents we need safe roads especially for Children going and coming home from school We only need to look back a few months to see what a speeding car can do
Meldrews Dad, Wroughton says...
2:36pm Tue 15 Jul 08
jo-ent, Swndon says...
3:22pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Robins69, swindon says...
5:49pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Mumstheword, Walcot says...
5:52pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Grumpy old man wrote:Honestly! I told you about a fatality on that stretch of road yesterday!
Well I'll go ahead with my guess. I'd wager zero, zilch, nadda, nil point. Point is, a speed camera does not discriminate - a car weaving between lanes, with the driver on his phone while drinking some coffee and having a ciggy, whilst applying makeup but under the speed limit will not be caught by any speed prevention measure. However, a safe, sensible middle aged bloke who is being observant all around him and goes at 5mph above a speed limit that was set donkeys years ago will be caught and fined. What we need is real traffic police with a remit to catch BAD driving, not fast driving. (the two are not mutually exclusive - bad driving could include driving too fast for the conditions but within speed limit) You yourself hit the nail on the head when you said you saw plenty of POOR driving. That can be but is not always fast driving. What we really need is a "Stupid" camera but they haven't invented that yet! :-)
Time_waits_for_no_ma
n, Swindon says...
6:03pm Tue 15 Jul 08
swindonian, swindon says...
6:15pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Time_waits_for_no_ma
n, Swindon says...
6:40pm Tue 15 Jul 08
swindonian wrote:How it the devil would you quantify or prove that. Yes if the Council was getting the money and redirecting back into the town for improvements- fair comment, but they are not - FACT - hence the idea of scrapping the 'cash machines' and using the money for local SAFETY improvements and not lining the government coffers....
If the council were getting all the revenue from the cameras they would be in favour of them. Think and answer this question honestly If the cameras saved only one life and it was your son, daughter, wife or husband would you then think they where worth every penney
kyoceran, swindon says...
8:35pm Tue 15 Jul 08
kyoceran, swindon says...
8:39pm Tue 15 Jul 08
bootersmate, Park South says...
9:11pm Tue 15 Jul 08
mrptoyou, swindon says...
9:31pm Tue 15 Jul 08
MauriceMalpasClueles
sNumpty, Swindon says...
10:03pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Casual Observer, Swindon says...
10:50pm Tue 15 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez wrote:Hehehe.. brilliant stuff RMF, very funny - you should ask someone knowledgeable how to get your own blog going. Ask them about that odd shaped key on your keyboard as well, like a large upside-down 'L'... yes that's the one it's called the Return key... allows you to put breaks in your paragraphs - makes your scripts more readable.
Returning from my radio show last night, I noticed that a flashing 30 mile an hour sign has been erected on Oxford Road, I also noted that prior to the speed camera there is a traffic flow monitoring device. It seems SBC took notice of my suggestion that to test the efficiency of the flashing signs there needs to be a camera nearby. In this way it can be shown either that the flashing signs stop speeding by a reduction in those caught on Camera, or it doesn't work. I know what my money is on. Well done who ever took this action. As for the removal of cameras, as has been said if they are a road safety measure then forget the fine, and impose more points. But we know it's about revenue. I am confident the flashing signs will have a far greater effect.
Public Spirit, Wiltshire says...
12:36am Wed 16 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez, Swindon says...
6:53am Wed 16 Jul 08
Neil, Swindon says...
8:49am Wed 16 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez, Swindon says...
9:19am Wed 16 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez, Swindon says...
9:24am Wed 16 Jul 08
Robert Feal-Martinez, Swindon says...
9:28am Wed 16 Jul 08
Add your comment
Register for a FREE Swindon Advertiser account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.
Please register now or sign in below to continue.
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find your next job now in Swindon and beyond
Search Now »
Make a date in Swindon now!
Search Now »
Swindon homes for sale and to let
Search Now »
Cars for sale in Swindon and Wiltshire
Search Now »
thutch, highworth says...
10:44am Tue 15 Jul 08